Lecture 3
Theory X and Theory Y
Continuing from the previous lecture, where
we learnt Excellence through the tower building exercise lecture 2 was about
Theory X and Theory Y. It is about differentiating the authoritative management
from participative style of management and to study, the implications each have
on the output and mind set of the employee.
Let’s assume, X and Y are two types of
managers where X thinks his employees are lazy and inefficient whereas manager
Y believes his workers are not lazy and hard working.
Hence, there are four situations that arise:
a. My employer is lazy and I
think they are lazy.
b. My employer is not
lazy but I still think they are lazy.
c. My employer is lazy
but I still believe they are not lazy.
d. My employer is not
lazy and I think they are not lazy.
Scenario
1: Lazy Employees and Theory X Manager
In this kind of a scenario
employees are lazy and the manager assumes them to be lazy. This type of
scenario is not going to help the
company .It is very important for the manager to keep their employees motivated
and by thinking them to be lazy he /she is demoralising the employees. This would not lead to decrease in efficiency
of the company
Scenario 2:
Employees are not lazy and Theory X Manager
In such a scenario,
the employees are not lazy and the theory X manager assumes that his employees
are lazy. The scenario is very dangerous because there will be highly skilled
and hardworking employees who will feel demotivated to be under such
management. This might lead to frequent strikes by the employees and also high
attrition rate. Usually the manager expects a lot out of employees , and hence
as expectation is high , he is never satisfied and find his employees to be
lazy
Scenario
3: Lazy Employees and Theory Y Manager
In this scenario, the
employees are lazy and the theory Y manager assumes that his employees are not
lazy or still contributing to the organization. This is a scenario which
I feel should be followed, because it keeps the employees motivated. Such
organizations initially perform poorly but in course of time they improve and
evolve dramatically. This is a
situation which not only boosts your morale but also helps in building your
relationship with your manager
Eg. – Almost all the big
companies follow such a scenario of motivating their employees
Scenario 4: Not Lazy Employees and
Theory Y Manager
This scenario is the
most ideal scenario where the employees are not lazy and the theory Y manager
assumes that his employees are not lazy. This can be called as perfect since the hardworking employees are highly
motivated by the measures adopted by the manager . Goals set by the managers are easily achieved
with high level of accuracy within a short span of time. The attrition rates are very low in these
organizations and high performance is always achieved
I am in ISEM, I am sure this blog is going to help me in POM.
ReplyDelete