Sunday, July 29, 2012


Tower Building - in depth analysis



Factor  1 to 8
Scenario – I
 Scenario - II
 Scenario - III
 Scenario - IV
 1 & 2
Historical Tower height achieved by team
 Low - 5

High -  18
 Low - 5

High - 20
  Low – 5

High – 21
 Low - 5

High - 23
 3
Achievable Performance -          ( Estimate / Guess )

 18 +

20+

 22+

 25+
4
Goal proposed by the Manager
 18
 22
22
 18
5
Goal proposed by the worker
12
 12
 12
20
 6
Goal Mutually agreed for building the tower between worker and manager with the support of the manager
 15
22
 18
  15
 7
No. of cubes Tower manager and worker team could build / achieve at the end of the exercise
18
 18
 18
18
8
P O T E N T I A L
T O W E R  
H E I G H T  ( assumption)

20
22
25
25+



My Analysis

 Sl. No.
Measure for Managerial Excellence
 Scenario – I
 Scenario – II
 Scenario – III
 Scenario – IV
1
Gap if any between Tower height  so far achieved and Achievable performance of tower ( Factor 3 and 7)

The achievable performance estimated by the manager was 18+ and the worker could achieve 18 which show that the manager pushed the worker by constant motivation.
The achievable performance estimated by the manager was 20+ and the worker could achieve 18 which show that although the manager trusted the worker but he could not motivate him enough to achieve the set goal

The achievable performance estimated by the manager was 22+ and the worker could achieve 18 which show that the goal set was too high for the worker who has estimated the number as 12 only.
The achievable performance estimated by the manager was 25+ and the worker could achieve 18 which show that the team did not work well together at all.
2
Gap if any between goal proposed by the Goal proposed by the Manager and mutually agreed team goal 
 ( Factor 4 and 6)
The goal proposed by the Manager is 18 and mutually agreed team goal is 15. This shows that the team has a sense of reluctance; the worker does not trust the manager.

The goal proposed by the Manager is 22 and mutually agreed team goal is 22. This shows that the team is in perfect sync, the worker  trusts the manager
The goal proposed by the Manager is 22 and mutually agreed team goal is 18. This shows that the worker is not willing to give his best; he already has estimated a very low number for himself.
The goal proposed by the Manager is 18 and mutually agreed team goal is 15. This shows that the team has a sense of reluctance, the worker does not trust the manager
3
Gap if any between goal proposed by the manger and the goal proposed  by the worker 
 ( Factor 4 and 5)
The goal proposed by the manager is 18 and the goal proposed by the worker is 12. The manager is a  Y type manager, he motivates his workers but the worker is lazy and not willing to work
The goal proposed by the manger is 22 and the goal proposed by the worker is 12. The manager is a  Y type manager, he motivates his workers but the worker is lazy and not willing to work
The goal proposed by the manger is 18 and the goal proposed by the worker is 12. The manager is a  Y type manager, he motivates his workers but the worker is lazy and not willing to work
The goal proposed by the manger is 18 and the goal proposed by the worker is 20. The manager is a  X type manager, he does not trust his workers while the worker is willing to work
4
Gap if any between goal proposed by the worker  and mutually agreed goal by team
 ( Factor 5 and 6)

The goal proposed by the worker is 12 and mutually agreed goal by team is 15. This shows that the manager was able to motivate the worker to increase his goal and to aim at a higher target than what he had proposed for himself  

The goal proposed by the worker is 12 and mutually agreed goal by team is 22. This shows that the manager was able to motivate the worker to increase his goal and to aim at a higher target than what he had proposed for himself  

The goal proposed by the worker is 12 and mutually agreed goal by team is 18. This shows that the manager was able to motivate the worker to increase his goal and to aim at a higher target than what he had proposed for himself  

The goal proposed by the worker is 20 and mutually agreed goal by team is 15. This shows that the manager was a X type manager, he believes his worker is lazy and that is why even when the worker proposes to do 20 he reduces the target to 15.
5
Gap if any between achievable performance  and potential tower
 ( Factor 3 and 8)

The worker was able to do as much as was the achievable performance.
The worker was able to do a little less than the achievable performance.
The worker performance was less than the achievable performance.
The worker has done a lot less than the achievable performance.
6
Gap if any between  performance achieved ( at the end of the exercise ) and  goal mutually agreed by manger and the worker  
( Factor 6 and 7)

The manager motivated the worker to achieve more than the agreed goal.
The worker was not able to achieve the agreed goal.
The worker achieved as much as was the agreed goal.
The manager motivated the worker to achieve more than the agreed goal.
7
Gap if any between  performance achieved ( at the end of the exercise ) and  achievable goal  
 ( Factor 7 and 3)

The gap is slightly less. The manager was able to motivate the worker.
The gap exists. The manager was not able to motivate the worker.
There is a noticeable gap. The manager was able to motivate the worker.
The gap is very large. The manager was able to motivate the worker and could not get even close to the target.
8
Gap if any between  performance achieved ( at the end of the exercise ) and  the potential  
 ( Factor 7 and 8)

The potential is not determinable so there will always be a gap.


The potential is not determinable so there will always be a gap.


The potential is not determinable so there will always be a gap.


The potential is not determinable so there will always be a gap.


Monday, July 23, 2012


THE 3 MONKS



The subject has given me lots of surprising experiences . The activities which happens during the class gives us a practical example of the theories of management  we are supposed to know. Last class we saw a video, a short animated chines movie. I don’t know about others but I loved it. It was a nice break from the usual classes( not the POM class but the other classes :D)
Please go through the video once.Link given below :





ABOUT THE MOVIE


Three Monks is a Chinese animated feature film produced by the Shanghai Animation Film Studio. After the cultural and the fall of the political Gang of Four in 1976, the film was one of the first animations created as part of the rebirth period. It is also referred to as The Three Buddhist Priests.


PLOT











A young monk lives a simple life in a temple on top of a hill. He has one daily task of hauling two buckets of water up the hill. He tries to share the job with another monk, but the carry pole is only long enough for one bucket. The arrival of a third monk prompts everyone to expect that someone else will take on the chore. Consequently, no one fetches water though everybody is thirsty. At night, a rat comes to scrounge and then knocks the candleholder, leading to a devastating fire in the temple. The three monks finally unite together and make a concerted effort to put out the fire. Since then they understand the old saying "unity is strength" and begin to live a harmonious life. The temple never lacks water again.


ANALYSIS – THROUGH MY EYES




At one point of time the movie shows that two people are 

trying to carry a single bucket, hanging from the bar held on 

their shoulders. Each one tries to push it towards the other 

in order to carry less weight. This is a common scene in 

most of the organisations today where the employees want 

to shift their responsibility to other fellow employees.


When asked in class about the solution to the problem of 
sharing load, a lot of them came up with different solutions.. 
The solution was quite simple - measure the centre using a scale. It can be related to an organisation too. There is always a simple solution. The only problem is discovering it .


Next, we noticed in the video , how the process of bringing 

the water uphill is changed when the second monk arrives. 

The single monk was carrying water everyday, but when the 

second monk arrived, they both started sharing the load. 

They updated the process so that all resources are optimally 

utilized – TEAM WORK .



But but but….. the team work was short lived… They started 

transferring their load to each other. This shows the violation 

of the team work principle.






When the third monk comes, the quarrel become even more 

intense. No one was willing to bring water and was ordering 

the other person to do it. Infact, once when the 3rd monk got 

water, after climbing the top, he himself consumed it. This 

shows selfishness in an organisation.



At night when they sleep, we see that the the monastery catches fire. There was no water in the monastery at that time. When this happens, all the monks forget their hostility and try to put out the fire. The dilemma of who will carry the water was quickly forgotten and a system arose out of the initial chaos. They all put out the fire quickly .Moral :Many a times crisis situations are encountered where any kind of system is in place. Infact one should be ready for it and should not keep anything for tomorrow and do their work today itself. In the end we see that the monks resolve the situation by fixing a pulley and dividing their roles - hooking the bucket, roping it in and transporting to the monastery. A fairly simple solution!!



AWARDS WON BY THE FILM




·  Won the outstanding film award at China's Ministry of Culture.
·   Won the Best animated film prize at the first Golden Rooster Awards in 1981.
·  Won four international awards including a Silver Bear for Short Film at the 32nd Berlin Film                             Festival in 1982.

Wednesday, July 11, 2012

How did the 3 Idiots cross the valley ?? ( team-work principle)


The valley crossing exercise was performed to provide an idea of the concept of teamwork. 

Team - Work??



It is the work performed by a group that contributes towards a mutual goal. In business and healthcare settings, teamwork is commonly seen as two or more professionals combining their skills to contribute towards the attainment of mutual goals. In sports, around the world people combine their talents to achieve the (usually) hotly desired win on the field. In any setting, teamwork involves a group of persons with different strengths combining those strengths to reach a mutually desired outcome. Most situations will call for a team leader, or a team member whose personality and teamwork skill will put them in position of strength relative to others in the group, and that team leader will direct the others in the process they use to move towards the goal. In all venues, the work of the many combines to increase the strength of them all.







Why Team work is important?


Well its one thing to create a team but quite an another to create teamwork in the workplace. Just its one thing to join a team, quite another to perform as a team member. To put it in simple words, teams doesn’t work without teamwork. Creating a culture where teamwork is valued, and collaboration encouraged, is a good way for businesses, sports teams, medical facilities, and really, most all human endeavors to increase the overall chances of mutual ongoing success. There are no two human beings that have the same experiences in their lives, and it is the sum of experience that “makes the man”. Just as you can never know precisely how a given situation will actually end, you can also never know how any teams endeavors will culminate either. All that can be done is to gather your team, and assign a project. Allow the leadership to come forward naturally, (usually they are quite easy to spot-vocal and opinionated) decide who should be named formally the teams leader, and begin your bigger journey.

 


 Exercise


 

As shown in the figure above , 3 people have to cross the valley which is more than 1 step long but less than 2 steps long. Also they have to carry the rod along with them. At any time all three people will be holding the rod. When the first person will come exactly on the top of the valley, he will be hanging and other 2 will be holding them. Similarly it will happen for the other two people when they will come exactly at the top of the valley.All the three members  have interchanging roles in the completion of the task .If we look closely at the table of the steps of the exercise we would notice that the here friends have equal distribution of risky ,half-risky and no-risky. A big part of this exercise is in the preparation of the exercise. All the movement must be properly synchronous for proper completion of the task. All the three members while crossing the river communicate and coordinate with each other through sound/signal. We also see that the structuring of the Team Roles is very important the completion of the task.

 

We have the following observations:-



 1)   All three members have equal distribution of different   kinds of situation :

High Risk 01 times
Half Risks 02 times
Fully Safe 02 times

    2)   All three members have the same role in terms of effort and risk. Nobody was overloaded or relaxed.

    3)  Communication and feedback is essential while working in a team.

    4)  Every member is indispensable in completing the task.

    5)  There were equal instances when one needed each other.

 

 

Lessons Learnt :

1)    Innovation:


When a team has gelled and is working effectively with one another, innovation will see an all-time high. It's not surprising to see a link between innovation and a good team





2)    Trust: 

The organization cannot be successful if there is no element of trust in it. As in the case of valley problem, persons can take the risk to cross the valley only since they trust the other two. Similarly for the organization to be successful, managers and workers have to follow the Theory X which tells the people or managers have trust on the other people or employees



3)    Responsibility:

Everybody in the organization is equally responsible, no matter if he/she is the higher manager, manager or the engineer/ worker. One irresponsible person can spoil the entire work chain.